Cole Haan Pinch Cup Penny Loafer in Saddle Tan available at Robert Frost Fine Footwear and www.frostshoes.com. This handsewn penny loafer has a leather upper and is leather lined. The Pinch Cup Penny is fully padded for extra comfort and has a rubber outsole. Cole Haan Pinch Cup Penny Loafer runs true to size at Robert Frost Fine Footwear and www.frostshoes.com.